What Should We Fix First? Introducing the DeRISK™ Consultant

Donovan TindillDeNexus
7 min read

Why OT programs move from checklists to financial decisions, and how the DeRISK™ Consultant recommends what to fix first.

Between 2003 and 2011, I led the same cyber risk assessment four times for a gas and electric utility, covering more than 4,500 cyber assets each round. Every report ended with a long list of valid gaps, and every leadership team asked the same question: what do we fix first, and what does it buy us?

That question has not changed in two decades. What has not kept pace is the supply of people who can answer it. Senior OT assessors who understand the frameworks, the plant floor, and the business are scarce, and their work is still done by hand, one facility at a time.

When the answer is done well, the payoff is real. At one industrial operator with dozens of wind and solar sites, expert judgment combined with DeNexus™ cyber risk quantification (aka., CRQ) produced a multi-year remediation roadmap that cut expected annual loss by nearly a fifth. The DeRISK™ Consultant exists to make that kind of answer repeatable.

Three ways OT cybersecurity programs make decisions

Over 25 years, I have watched OT cybersecurity programs pass through transition points where the way they make decisions changes. Each stage builds on the one before it.

Checklist-based. Most programs start here, when knowledge of cyber is low and the organization leans on published guidance. The weakness is that checklists are written for every industry and every facility, regardless of risk profile, revenue, or vertical. Even so, it is a good way to start making progress on something.

Risk-based. Later, the organization knows enough about its own business to bring in the company risk matrix. Spending moves toward higher-criticality facilities and more important network zones, and controls are applied more selectively. The limitation is the scale itself: a rating of 1 to 5, or red, yellow and green, says which risk is bigger but not by how much in dollars.

Financially quantified. The emerging third stage keeps the foundations of the first two and adds financial metrics for the organization, each facility, its telemetry, and the networks within. Instead of applying the top five checklist items or chasing the red box on the matrix, the program proceeds with the mitigations that reduce the most financial loss.

Meet the DeRISK™ Consultant

The DeRISK™ Consultant is an add-on module to DeRISK™ CRQ built for that third stage. Working with DeRISK™ CRQ, its job is to identify the mitigations that are most effective at reducing financial loss, and to put them in a sensible order.

It builds on the baseline set by the Assessor, the DeRISK™ agent that scores an operator's security controls on three questions:

  • What elements of the security program are covered? Evaluating all aspects of the OT cybersecurity program, like all functions Govern to Recover in NIST CSF, are evaluated and assessed.
  • How mature is the process behind it? From ad hoc, through developing and basic, to organized, quantitatively managed, and optimizing, building on the harmonized maturity levels I have written about before.[1]
  • How technically strong is it? From basic hygiene, through intermediate, to sophisticated.

If the Assessor tells you where you stand, the Consultant tells you what to do next.

Two ways to reduce financial loss

The Consultant was built with loss reduction in mind, so every recommendation targets one of two financial levers:

  1. Reduce the probability of an event (aka., loss event frequency). Stronger protective safeguards and earlier, pre-incident detection make it less likely that an attacker reaches the point of causing a loss. If the frequency is halved, the financial impact is also half.
  2. Reduce the severity of the consequence (aka., loss magnitude). Post-incident detection, response, and recovery shorten the incident, and in OT, downtime usually drives the bill. If the event duration is halved, the financial impact is also half. If cyber is part of engineering, it can also considerably reduce losses as well.

The Consultant weighs both levers for each recommendation. It then picks the one that best fits the facility's current state and where it sits on its cybersecurity maturity journey.

That journey is the pathway every OT program ascends, from ad hoc through developing and basic to organized and beyond, as its controls become more dependable. The best next step for a low maturity site looks very different from the best next step for a high maturity site, even when both face the same threat.

Built on OT field experience

An AI recommendation is only as credible as the judgment behind it. For the Consultant, that judgment comes from DeNexus research: structured interviews with peer OT cyber defense and response experts, each with at least 15 years in the field, combined with my own 25+ years of OT assessment and advisory work.

Every expert answered the same core question: which controls reduce financial loss the most in ICS/OT environments, in what order, and why? Their backgrounds span OT architecture, assessment, incident response, engineering, consulting, product security, and asset-owner advisory. Their insights became a research-backed method, and that method is what the DeRISK™ Consultant applies to each facility.

The result is a Consultant that understands the typical path an OT environment follows from zero to superhero. It checks that the right foundations are in place before it recommends more advanced controls, because an advanced control on a weak foundation rarely delivers the loss reduction it promises.

What to solve, not how to solve it

Any OT cyber risk can be mitigated in many different ways. Take “segment the network” or “improve the backup strategy”: one site may solve it with extra staff and a lot of labor, another with a large investment in new technology, and a third by outsourcing the work to a managed service provider (MSP). Each path has very different costs, so no one can put a single price or timeline on the fix until the organization chooses its path.

That is why the Consultant deliberately stays out of the “how.” It identifies what needs to be solved for the greatest risk reduction: the remediation project, its scope, and its order of priority. DeRISK™ CRQ then quantifies how much financial risk each recommended project removes.

The organization stays in control of the rest. You choose the path that suits your people, budget, and operating model, and your own business case sets its cost against the quantified risk reduction.

Who the DeRISK™ Consultant helps

Risk owners. Plant managers, OT security leaders, and the executives who fund them get two things: a next-best recommendation, the single project that removes the most financial loss right now, and an OT cyber roadmap that sequences the projects after it across people, process, and technology. Both can be steered by what is driving the program, whether that is reducing risk, meeting a compliance obligation, or staying insurable.

Consultants. Traditional OT consultants can add a financial lens to the assessments they already deliver, so their recommendations arrive with a quantified case for the budget holder. IT security consultants can add OT depth to their practice, grounded in how OT environments actually lose money.

Timely Reporting. Instead of annual security assessment reports, DeRISK™ can assess and advise as material improvements to your security program or the threat landscape changes.

From checklists to financial decisions

Checklists got most OT programs moving, and risk matrices taught them to focus. The next transition is to fund the work that removes the most financial loss, and to know why each project comes before the next one. For two decades, that answer has depended on finding the right senior expert with enough time to give it. The DeRISK™ Consultant puts that expertise to work on every facility, so the question I heard at the end of every assessment finally has a repeatable answer.

References

  1. [1]
    Tindill, Donovan. “Harmonizing OT Cybersecurity Maturity Models.” DeNexus, 5 Feb. 2026, www.denexus.io/resources/harmonizing-ot-cybersecurity-maturity-models. Accessed 26 Oct. 2026.
Share